Canada’s economy is set to follow the U.S. off a cliff if it holds the same pattern America’s did in the mid-2000s.
The Great White North’s dependence on real estate investment reached a record high this year — just like it did in the U.S. in 2005, before it started dropping for years, global banking firm Macquarie noted in a report this week.
It said that 2016 could represent a “peak housing” year for Canada, and that activity in the sector could start declining afterward.
Economists with the firm looked at how residential investment trended as a share of the U.S. economy between 1991 and 2005. Then it looked at how such investment has trended in Canada from 2001 up to the present.
And, well, just look at the similarities:
The graph above shows a pattern of growing dependence on residential investment in Canada, not unlike that seen in the U.S. over a similar period.
Much of the growth in Canadian residential investment has come from “brokers’ commissions and other ownership transfer costs” — again, just like in the U.S.
But those aren’t the only alarming signs that Macquarie noted for Canada’s economy.
The research showed that new mortgages have become “reliant on risky borrowers”:
It also remarked that a growing share of mortgages have loan-to-income ratios of over 450 per cent.
And that suggests homebuyers are borrowing way more than they can pay back.
This trend was readily apparent in many cities, but especially Vancouver and Toronto:
The report came days after the federal Liberals announced new mortgage rules.
The rules include a stress test to make sure insured borrowers can afford their mortgages if interest rates go up.
Macquarie said these changes are likely to “slow housing and create headwinds for Canadian economic activity.”
Homes for sale in Toronto. (Photo: CP)
But the firm saw promising signs for Canada’s economy thanks to factors such asfederal infrastructure spending, which is expected to support GDP growth of 1.8 per cent next year and 1.7 per cent the following year.
Macquarie also saw some hope in Canada’s energy sector, which is set to see an end to capital expenditure declines, it said.
Capital spending on Canadian oil and natural gas has dropped by 62 per cent over the past two years as the price of oil has plummeted, the Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers (CAPP) noted in April.
The oil extraction industry expects to be profitable again next year, said the Conference Board of Canada.
The industry is, however, headed for a $10-billion loss in 2016, it added.